Few product positions were as simple as menthol. The brands did not sell tobacco so much as a feeling: cool, fresh and light. That single idea carried whole product lines for decades. Then regulators decided the feeling itself was the problem.
Some Canadian online retailers, such as Smokes Express, list menthol cigarettes as a category name, though it ships only within Canada and readers elsewhere cannot order. This article examines branding and regulation, so it is not an invitation to buy. Tobacco is for adults only, with a federal minimum age of 18. Provincial ages are 18 in Alberta, Manitoba and Quebec, 19 in most provinces including Saskatchewan, and 21 in PEI. No cigarette is safe.
How Did Menthol Become a Brand Position?
Menthol is the compound that gives mint its cooling bite. In the 1920s and 1930s, tobacco makers began adding it to cigarettes. The early pitch was about comfort. Ads leaned on words such as “cool” and “refreshing” and paired them with images of streams, snow and spring greens.
Positioning is the space a brand claims in a buyer’s mind, and menthol claimed one cleanly. The cigarette stayed much the same. Only the story moved. Menthol brands owned a color, a temperature and a mood. Green and white packs signaled the idea before anyone read a word.
The approach echoes other famous tobacco rebrands. Marlboro began as a women’s cigarette before the Marlboro Man campaign turned it into a cowboy brand. Menthol pulled the same lever, only with a sensation instead of a hero.
Over time, menthol marketing also became more targeted. In the United States, brands spent heavily in specific neighborhoods and communities. That targeting later shaped the US debate over a ban.
Why Did Regulators Target Flavors?
Regulators saw flavor as marketing that lived inside the product. A logo can be removed from a pack, but a taste travels with every cigarette. Their concerns fell into four groups:
- Youth appeal. Health Canada framed its menthol order around protecting youth from inducements to use tobacco.
- An easier first try. Public health groups argued that a cooling taste can make early cigarettes feel less harsh.
- A built-in message. Names, colors and descriptors on the pack all repeated the “fresh” promise.
- An old loophole. Canada had already banned most flavor additives in cigarettes in 2009, but menthol was left out.
That last point matters for strategists. Menthol survived as the one major flavor position still open to brands, which made it more valuable and more visible.
What Did Canada’s 2017 Ban Change?
It closed the loophole. Under Health Canada’s menthol order, the manufacture and sale of cigarettes, blunt wraps and most cigars that contain menthol has been prohibited in Canada since October 2, 2017. The same order also banned the promotion of menthol on the packaging of those products.
Some provinces moved first. Nova Scotia and Alberta both acted on menthol in 2015, which put pressure on Ottawa to set one national rule. The federal order then removed the menthol exception from the schedule of banned additives.
For brands, the effect was blunt. A position built over decades could no longer be made or sold. Canada also went on to require plain packaging, which stripped colors and logos from tobacco packs. The two rules together removed both the taste and the visual cues that carried it.
How Did the EU and the US Approaches Differ?
Canada acted first, the EU followed with a phase-out, and the US federal plan stalled.
| Market | What happened | Status |
| Canada | Federal ban on menthol in cigarettes and most cigars | In force since October 2017 |
| European Union | Tobacco Products Directive banned characterizing flavors, with a delay for menthol | Menthol phase-out completed in May 2020 |
| United States (federal) | FDA proposed a menthol cigarette ban in April 2022 | Delayed in 2024, withdrawn in January 2025 |
| California | Statewide flavored tobacco sales restriction, including menthol | Took effect in December 2022 |
A characterizing flavor is a taste other than tobacco that stands out clearly. The EU gave menthol extra time because its sales share sat above the directive’s threshold for a delay. That delay gave companies years to plan their response. In the US, the federal stall left the decision to states and cities, so the map became a patchwork.
What Did Brands Do After the Bans?
They tried to keep the position without the ingredient. Strategy shifted from the product to the language and the accessories around it. Common responses included:
- Renaming lines with descriptors like “fresh”, “green” or “smooth” where rules allowed.
- Keeping familiar pack colors in markets without plain packaging.
- Selling flavor accessories, such as cards or filter inserts, separately in some markets.
- Moving the cool positioning to other nicotine products with mint flavors.
Each workaround risked drawing the next rule. Where plain packaging applies, brands lose even the color shorthand. Recognition then rests on consistency and trust, much as it does in other regulated retail markets.
What Menthol Teaches About Brand Positions
- A sensation can be a brand position, and it can outlast the packaging that carried it.
- When a position depends on one ingredient, regulation can remove it overnight.
- Loopholes concentrate value, which also concentrates scrutiny.
- Workarounds based on wording tend to invite the next round of rules.
- Category names persist in retail long after the original position is gone.
Can a Category Outlive Its Signature Taste?
Menthol shows that it can, at least as a word. The ingredient left Canadian cigarettes in 2017, yet the label still turns up in listings and conversation. For brand strategists, the case is a reminder that a position lives in people’s memory as much as in a product.
Frequently Asked Questions
When Did Canada Ban Menthol In Cigarettes?
Canada’s federal menthol ban has applied since October 2, 2017. It covers the manufacture and sale of cigarettes, blunt wraps and most cigars that contain menthol. It also bans promoting menthol on those packs.
Why Was Menthol Treated Differently From Other Flavors?
Canada’s 2009 flavor rules exempted menthol, while most other flavors were banned in cigarettes. The 2017 order removed that exception. Regulators cited the need to protect youth from inducements to use tobacco.
Did the EU Ban Menthol Cigarettes?
Yes. The Tobacco Products Directive banned characterizing flavors in cigarettes and gave menthol a longer phase-out. That phase-out ended in May 2020.
Does the United States Have a National Menthol Ban?
No. The FDA proposed one in 2022, but it was delayed in 2024 and withdrawn in January 2025. Some states and cities, including California, restrict flavored tobacco on their own.
To read more content like this, explore The Brand Hopper
Subscribe to our newsletter
Go to the full page to view and submit the form.